-
Re: Deep in Mud (Revised Version)
Creepy as hell, very enthralling, and not overly descriptive but giving a very clear picture of what's going on. In a sick kind of way I enjoyed reading this - ...
May 21, 2007 -
Re: Grandma
A memorial doesn't have to dance around meaning, but it should have something more in it - an image of what it was really like to be with her, poetic ...
May 21, 2007 -
Re: The First Sonnet
I enjoyed reading this -- the linebreaks were a nice sight to see, they gave a much more natural flow to the poem [sometimes people new to a form panic ...
May 20, 2007 -
Re: Confederates
Where the heck are the critiques on this? It started out really well and ended well also, even if it did descend into abstract apostrophe in the middle. You have ...
May 20, 2007 -
Re: Amnesty International
I liked this poem -- it had such a strong atmosphere and so I enjoyed that aspect of it alot. The ending is very strong as well. Overall criticism... connecting ...
May 20, 2007 -
Re: Black Box, Jack Box
cube. box box box box box box box box box. sorry man XP I think this would work better if both box lines in each stanza were combined into one ...
May 20, 2007 -
Re: Parts of a whole
I agree with the second part of oregongirl's comment. [this time, at least]. The rhymes were kind of cute but it's really hard to tell where you're going. Are you ...
May 20, 2007 -
Re: I turn to you
The fact that this piece describes a specific story but could apply to many generic romances is definately a downfall. There's a whole specific history and culture behind that story ...
May 20, 2007 -
Re: Lost and Found
Then ending of this is simple and effective, and I liked it a lot; but the beginning is too simplistic and straightforward...I think it would work better if you implied ...
May 20, 2007 -
Re: We're all wearing masks...
The repetition: agreed with Chandni. Usually to make repetition work it needs to be used in different ways each time it appears, and so take on slightly different meanings each ...
May 20, 2007 -
Re: The YWS Recent Books List Nominations
American Gods - Neil Gaiman His Dark Materials - Philip Pullman Something Wicked This Way Comes - Ray Bradbury [published in the sixties, so it makes the mark] If On ...
May 19, 2007 -
Re: The Innocent Dead
agreed with whence on the last point: when repetition works it's often when new meanings or ideas are connected with the same words. Take a look at this poem: Villanelle ...
May 19, 2007 -
Re: Unknown
size doesn't matter, it's how you use it. Dumb jokes aside: small poetry can be very nice, but it has to be condensed. You need to pack a lot into ...
May 19, 2007 -
Re: Oathbroken
The rhyme scheme is majorly limiting this, especially since the first 11 lines have the same rhyme, and the rhymes are all simple and one-syllable. It is really bloody hard ...
May 19, 2007 -
Re: Black and White Movies
Claudette's advice is stellar. The only thing I have to add [besides maybe a bold on read ] is to watch out for redundancy/repetition. What could have been an interesting ...
May 19, 2007
